This event is no longer in the live catalog. Showing its last saved snapshot.

Defensive Rookie of the Year Winner?
K 2.41M contracts
1
40
AI Analysis
Trader mode: Market mechanics, assumptions and risks
K 2.41M contracts
Reported volume · provider units
40
Saved contracts
0
Same-question pairs
Source snapshot: Nov 14, 2026, 12:00 PM UTC
Snapshot observed Nov 17, 2026, 3:00 AM UTC. This analysis describes that snapshot and is not a live news update.
What the contract measures
This is a sports prediction market asking who will win the Pro Football AP Defensive Rookie of the Year award for the 2026-27 season. Each named player has a separate Yes or No contract. On Kalshi, a contract resolves to Yes if the named player wins, and the market "will close and expire early if the event occurs" [1]. On Polymarket, the market resolves to the player who wins the 2026 AP NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year award. Ties follow official NFL rules, and if no winner is declared by the stated deadline, the market resolves to "Other" [2].
The two platforms word their rules differently, so their prices do not describe identical questions. Polymarket names a specific resolution path and an "Other" outcome. Kalshi's excerpt says it is not affiliated with the governing league [1].
Reading the snapshot
The snapshot was observed at Nov 17, 2026, 3:00 AM UTC and retrieved at Nov 17, 2026, 3:07 AM UTC. These are records of a past moment, not live quotes. Prices are shown only as recorded in that snapshot.
Within Kalshi, Arvell Reese's Yes contract was priced at 0.555 and David Bailey's at 0.195. Within Polymarket, Reese's Yes contract was priced at 0.5405 and Bailey's at 0.22. These figures come from different platforms with different wording, so they should not be averaged or treated as one consensus. Each price is a snapshot of one market, not a verified probability or an executable quote.
Coverage differs. Kalshi's event has 40 total markets, and 12 are included here, so this is a partial sample. Polymarket's event has 8 markets, and all 8 are included. The sample ranks included markets by Yes price, so omitted players are not shown to have lower prices. The reported volumes are 2,516,504 contracts on Kalshi and $34,796 on Polymarket. These figures use different units, do not measure liquidity, and cannot be compared.
What remains uncertain
The listed close times differ. Kalshi's excerpt says its listed end time is "not supplied" [1], while the market records show an end date of 2028-02-28. Polymarket's event lists an end time of Mar 1, 2027, 4:59 AM UTC [2], and some individual markets show earlier dates such as 2027-02-11. A listed close time is not the award announcement date.
The evidence does not explain why any price moved, how many traders hold each view, or how well either platform has forecast past awards. Because the Kalshi sample is partial, the prices shown are only some of the players in that event.
References
- Kalshi: Defensive Rookie of the Year Winner?. Provider data observed Nov 17, 2026, 3:00 AM UTC.
- Polymarket: Pro Football: 2026-27 AP Defensive Rookie of the Year Winner. Provider data observed Nov 17, 2026, 3:00 AM UTC.
Snapshot observed Nov 17, 2026, 3:00 AM UTC. This analysis describes that snapshot and is not a live news update.
What the contract measures
Both provider events cover the same award, but their rules are worded differently. Kalshi's rule states that "If X wins the Pro Football AP Defensive Rookie of the Year in the 2026-27 season, then the market resolves to Yes" [1]. Polymarket ties resolution to the winner of the 2026 Associated Press NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year award for the 2026-27 season. It also includes a tie-break by listed last name and resolves to "Other" if the season is cancelled or no winner is declared by February 28, 2027, 11:59 PM ET [2]. The Kalshi excerpt does not describe a comparable fallback.
Listed end times also differ. Kalshi's market end date fields show Feb 28, 2028, 3:00 PM UTC [1], while Polymarket's show Mar 1, 2027, 4:59 AM UTC or Feb 11, 2027, 11:59 PM UTC depending on the player [2]. The Kalshi event excerpt says "Listed end time: not supplied," so its end date fields should be treated as provider data to verify, not as a confirmed resolution date.
Reading the snapshot
The prices were observed at Nov 17, 2026, 3:00 AM UTC and retrieved at 03:07:56.533Z, so they describe that snapshot only. Each figure is a quoted Yes or No value, not an executable price or a verified probability.
On Kalshi, the Yes price for Arvell Reese was 0.555 and for David Bailey was 0.195 [1]. On Polymarket, the Yes price for Reese was 0.5405 and for Bailey was 0.22 [2]. These are separate contracts with different wording and close times, so any difference between them is not an arbitrage opportunity, and the two platforms' prices should not be averaged.
The Kalshi sample includes 12 of 40 markets and is partial. The other 28 are not shown and cannot be ranked against the included markets. The Polymarket sample includes all 8 of its markets. Reported volumes are in different units (2,516,504 contracts on Kalshi and $34,796 on Polymarket) and should not be compared. Volume is not liquidity or a count of traders.
What remains uncertain
The evidence does not explain why any price is where it is, and it does not show how many traders hold each view. It also does not include recent reporting on the award or any historical accuracy data. The Kalshi excerpt does not supply a listed end time, and its end date fields differ from the Polymarket listed times. Readers should check each provider's current rules directly before relying on either contract's wording.
References
- Kalshi: Defensive Rookie of the Year Winner?. Provider data observed Nov 17, 2026, 3:00 AM UTC.
- Polymarket: Pro Football: 2026-27 AP Defensive Rookie of the Year Winner. Provider data observed Nov 17, 2026, 3:00 AM UTC.
AI-generated analysis based on market data. Not financial advice.
Saved Nov 17, 2026 UTCOverview
Defensive Rookie of the Year Winner? is a Kalshi event tied to the Pro Football AP Defensive Rookie of the Year award for the 2026-27 season. Each contract in the event asks whether one named player will win that award. According to the contract rules, if the named player wins the Pro Football AP Defensive Rookie of the Year in the 2026-27 season, the market resolves to Yes [1]. The rules also state that the market will close and expire early if that event occurs [1]. The listed end time is not supplied in the provider record [1], so the closing and resolution timing for any contract should be read from the contract rules rather than assumed from other dates. The award itself is presented by the Associated Press. The AP NFL Rookie of the Year is an annual award that recognizes the top first-year offensive and defensive players in the National Football League, and winners are selected by a nationwide panel of 50 members of the AP who regularly cover the league [3]. The contract refers to the defensive version of this honor. Separate organizations present their own rookie awards, but the NFL considers the AP awards its official honor [2]. The contract's wording also includes a disclaimer that Kalshi is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or officially connected to the governing league, and that trademarks belong to their respective owners [1]. This is a statement about the provider's relationship to the league and does not change how the award is defined for resolution.
Historical Context
The AP has chosen a defensive rookie of the year since 1967, and an offensive rookie of the year since 1957 [3]. Since 2011, the AP awards have been presented at the NFL Honors [2]. For the 2025 season, the AP named Carolina Panthers wide receiver Tetairoa McMillan as the offensive winner and Cleveland Browns linebacker Carson Schwesinger as the defensive winner [3]. These are historical records of past seasons and do not indicate the status of the 2026-27 award.
Why It Matters
The contract measures a single outcome: whether the named player is selected as the Pro Football AP Defensive Rookie of the Year for the 2026-27 season [1]. Because the AP award is chosen by a panel of AP members who cover the league [3], the resolution depends on that official selection rather than on general opinions about rookies or on statistics alone. Prices shown for these contracts are snapshots of market activity at the time they were observed, so they reflect the market's trading levels at that moment rather than verified probabilities or prices a trader could execute.
Snapshot context
The latest published provider snapshot for this topic was observed on 2026-11-11 at 12:00 UTC. It contains listings from Kalshi. Market descriptions and listed closing times define the contracts; they do not establish that the real-world outcome has occurred. This article does not include a separately verified news update. [1]
Frequently Asked Questions
What must happen for a contract in this event to resolve to Yes?
The contract resolves to Yes if the named player wins the Pro Football AP Defensive Rookie of the Year in the 2026-27 season [1].
Does this event close early?
The rules state that the market will close and expire early if the event occurs [1]. The listed end time is not supplied in the provider record [1].
Who selects the AP Defensive Rookie of the Year?
Winners are selected by a nationwide panel of 50 members of the Associated Press who regularly cover the NFL [3].
Is the AP award the same as other rookie awards?
Various entities present rookie of the year awards each season, but the NFL considers the AP awards to be its official honor [2].
AI-written background. References identify the evidence used; Wikipedia links under Learn More are additional reading. Prices and provider rules are dated snapshots. This is not financial advice.
Related prediction markets
Prices are catalog snapshots and may have changed. Check each market's rules and observation time.

Defensive Player of the Year Winner?
PM $87.4K · K 11.25M contractsWill Patrick Mahomes win the 2026 NFL Comeback Player of the Year award for the 2026-27 NFL season?
Kalshi: Will Patrick Mahomes win the Comeback Player of the Year?
Same question, fine print differs
Will Will Anderson Jr. win the 2026 NFL Defensive Player of the Year award for the 2026-27 NFL season?
Kalshi: Will Will Anderson Jr. win the Defensive Player of the Year?
Related contracts
Will Arvell Reese win the 2026 NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year award for the 2026-27 NFL season?
Kalshi: Will Arvell Reese win the Defensive Rookie of the Year?
Related contracts
Related or unreviewed contracts may settle differently. Their gap is not an equivalent-contract comparison.
Saved prices; check contract rules.

Defensive Rookie of the Year Finalists
K 950.01 contracts
Rookie of the Year Finalists
PM $8.31M · K 3.61M contractsWill Cameron Boozer win the 2026-27 NBA Rookie of the Year?
Kalshi: Pro Basketball Rookie of the Year Finalists: Cameron Boozer
Related contracts
Will Yaxel Lendeborg win the 2026-27 NBA Rookie of the Year?
Kalshi: Pro Basketball Rookie of the Year Finalists: Yaxel Lendeborg
Related contracts
Will Hannes Steinbach win the 2026-27 NBA Rookie of the Year?
Kalshi: Pro Basketball Rookie of the Year Finalists: Hannes Steinbach
Related contracts
Related or unreviewed contracts may settle differently. Their gap is not an equivalent-contract comparison.
Saved prices; check contract rules.

Pro Basketball Defensive Player of the Year Winner
PM $3.6K · K 132.4K contractsWill Victor Wembanyama win the 2026-27 NBA Defensive Player of the Year?
Kalshi: Will Victor Wembanyama win Defensive Player of the Year?
Related contracts
Will Toumani Camara win the 2026-27 NBA Defensive Player of the Year?
Kalshi: Will Toumani Camara win Defensive Player of the Year?
Related contracts
Will Anthony Davis win the 2026-27 NBA Defensive Player of the Year?
Kalshi: Will Anthony Davis win Defensive Player of the Year?
Related contracts
Related or unreviewed contracts may settle differently. Their gap is not an equivalent-contract comparison.
Saved prices; check contract rules.

Women's Pro Basketball Defensive Player of the Year Winner
K 284.93 contracts
Men's Naismith Defensive Player of the Year Winner
K 0.01 contractsMarket Insights
Price gaps of 2 pp+
0
Same-question pairs
0
No outcomes on this page have been reviewed as the same question on both platforms yet.
Price differences do not establish arbitrage. Check each pair's review, current order prices, fees and settlement rules.
