This prediction market asks whether former Department of Justice Special Prosecutor Jack Smith will be formally charged or indicted by any federal, state, or local jurisdiction in the United States by March 31, 2026. Jack Smith served as the special counsel appointed by Attorney General Merrick Garland in November 2022 to oversee two major criminal investigations related to former President Donald Trump. The first investigation examined Trump's handling of classified documents after leaving the White House and his alleged obstruction of efforts to retrieve them. The second investigation focused on Trump's actions and attempts to overturn the 2020 presidential election results, culminating in the January 6 Capitol attack. Smith's high-profile prosecutions have made him a central figure in American political and legal discourse. Interest in this market stems from the intense political polarization surrounding these cases and the unprecedented nature of prosecuting a former president and leading candidate for the same office. Some political figures, including Trump himself, have publicly called for investigations or retribution against Smith, framing the prosecutions as politically motivated. This has led to speculation about whether Republican-led jurisdictions or future administrations might pursue charges against the prosecutor, testing the norms of the American legal system's independence.

Historical Context

The appointment of a special counsel to investigate a president or high-ranking official has historical precedent, but the context of investigating a former president who is actively campaigning for re-election is without modern parallel. The independent counsel law, which expired in 1999, led to high-profile investigations like Ken Starr's probe into President Bill Clinton in the 1990s. Since then, attorneys general have appointed special counsels under existing DOJ regulations, as with Robert Mueller's investigation into Russian interference in the 2016 election. The political aftermath of such investigations has often been contentious. Following the Mueller investigation, then-Attorney General William Barr was investigated by a district attorney in Washington, D.C., for potential campaign finance violations related to his 2020 election fundraising, though no charges were filed. This demonstrates that prosecutors themselves can become subjects of scrutiny. The concept of a 'tit-for-tat' prosecution, where a new administration investigates the prosecutors from the prior administration, challenges the traditional norm of Justice Department independence from political cycles. This norm was tested after the 2020 election when some Trump allies called for investigations into officials involved in the earlier Russia probe.

Frequently Asked Questions