This prediction market topic centers on whether Dave Portnoy, the founder of Barstool Sports and creator of the 'One Bite' pizza review series, will award a score of 9.0 or higher to any pizza establishment before January 1, 2027. Portnoy's pizza reviews, where he famously takes 'one bite' and delivers an immediate numerical score, have evolved from a viral internet segment into a significant cultural and economic force within the food industry. A score of 9.0 or above represents near-perfection in his rating system, an accolade he has historically been extremely reluctant to give, making such an event noteworthy. The market will resolve to 'Yes' if any review meets this threshold, and will close early if the event occurs, creating a dynamic betting environment based on Portnoy's notoriously unpredictable and subjective judging criteria. Interest in this market stems from Portnoy's massive influence, where a high score can dramatically boost a pizzeria's business, and from the ongoing debate among fans about whether his scoring has become more conservative over time. The question taps into broader discussions about food criticism in the digital age, the power of influencer marketing, and the elusive quest for culinary perfection as defined by one of the internet's most polarizing personalities.

Historical Context

Dave Portnoy's pizza review journey began unofficially around 2016, with early videos featuring casual, off-the-cuff reviews of pizzerias, primarily in the Northeast. The format crystallized with his signature 'one bite, everybody knows the rules' catchphrase. Historically, Portnoy was slightly more generous with top scores. In the series' earlier years, he awarded a 9.4 to Pepe's Pizzeria Napoletana in New Haven, Connecticut, in 2017, and a 9.1 to Sally's Apizza, also in New Haven, in 2019. These scores set a high-water mark that he has not approached in a formal review for several years. The creation of the One Bite app in 2019 formalized the community aspect, separating crowd ratings from Portnoy's personal scores. Since the sale of Barstool Sports and the expansion of his review travels nationwide, many observers note a tightening of his scoring scale, with scores in the 8.0-8.5 range becoming the new benchmark for excellence. The last score of 9.0 or above given in a standard video review was the 9.1 to Sally's Apizza in 2019, establishing a multi-year drought for the top tier of his rating system.

Frequently Asked Questions