
Howard Lutnick out as Commerce Secretary?
PM $522.8K · K 380.9K contracts
2
14

PM $522.8K · K 380.9K contracts
2
14
Polymarket vs Kalshi
Snapshot from
As of Nov 19, 2026, 6:00 PM UTC, December 31 is priced at 17.5% on Polymarket and 18.5% on Kalshi.
| Outcome (Yes price) | Polymarket | Kalshi | Gap |
|---|---|---|---|
| December 31Same question, fine print differs | 17.5% | 18.5% | 1.0 pts |
| November 30Same question, fine print differs | 5.5% | 4.5% | 1.0 pts |
Yes prices for outcomes an automated review found to ask the same question on both platforms. They are not order quotes; check each platform's rules, fees and live prices before trading.
AI Analysis
Trader mode: Market mechanics, assumptions and risks
PM $522.8K · K 380.9K contracts
Reported volume · provider units
14
Saved contracts
2
Same-question pairs
Source snapshot: Nov 19, 2026, 6:00 PM UTC
Snapshot observed Nov 19, 2026, 3:00 AM UTC. This analysis describes that snapshot and is not a live news update.
What the contract measures
These contracts ask whether Howard Lutnick will leave the post of U.S. Commerce Secretary within a set window. The two platforms word the question differently. Kalshi's rules say that temporary leaves, suspensions, or recusals do not count unless the person "formally and permanently ceases to hold the position" [1]. Polymarket's contract resolves "Yes" if he "ceases to be the US Secretary of Commerce for any period of time" before December 31, 2026, 11:59 PM ET, and an announced resignation or removal resolves it "Yes" regardless of when it takes effect [2].
Reading the snapshot
The prices were observed at Nov 19, 2026, 3:00 AM UTC and retrieved later that day, so they describe that moment and are not live quotes. Each price is a snapshot, not an executable quote or a verified probability.
Kalshi's event includes all twelve saved markets, each with a different deadline from November 2026 to January 2029 [1]. Yes prices rise as the deadline moves later, from 0.005 for "before Nov 20, 2026" to 0.885 for "before Jan 1, 2029." Polymarket's event includes both of its saved markets: a Yes price of 0.055 for a November 30 deadline and 0.175 for a December 31 deadline [2].
Platform figures should not be placed side by side as one ranking. Kalshi's "before Jan 1, 2027" market shows a Yes price of 0.205, but its listed close is Jan 8, 2027, 3:00 PM UTC [1]. Polymarket's December 31 market lists an end of Jan 1, 2027, 4:59 AM UTC and a different resolution wording [2]. A price gap between them reflects different terms and close times, not a trading opportunity.
Reported volume uses different units. Kalshi reports 371,501 contracts and Polymarket reports $515,759 [1][2]. Neither figure measures liquidity or the number of traders.
What remains uncertain
The evidence says all saved markets for these events are included, but that does not establish that the providers list every possible outcome. The evidence does not explain why prices changed or what information traders used. It also contains no recent news about Lutnick's position.
Kalshi's listed end time is not supplied [1]. Its resolution text also refers to "before Nov X 2026," which is unclear as quoted, so readers should check the full rules on the platform. The evidence describes resolution conditions but does not report that any departure has occurred.
References
- Kalshi: Howard Lutnick out as Commerce Secretary?. Provider data observed Nov 19, 2026, 3:00 AM UTC.
- Polymarket: Howard Lutnick out as Secretary of Commerce by...?. Provider data observed Nov 19, 2026, 3:00 AM UTC.
Snapshot observed Nov 19, 2026, 3:00 AM UTC. This analysis describes that snapshot and is not a live news update.
What the contract measures
Both providers ask whether Howard Lutnick will leave the Commerce Secretary role, but the wording differs. The Kalshi rules state that the market resolves to Yes if Lutnick leaves the role, and that "Temporary leaves of absence, suspensions, or recusals do not constitute leaving" [1]. Resignation, removal, and expiration of a term without renewal all count. The Kalshi excerpt also says the market "will close and expire early" if he leaves [1]. Its listed end time is "not supplied," and the excerpt contains the placeholder phrase "before Nov X 2026," so the specific dates should be checked in the full provider rules.
Polymarket resolves to Yes if Lutnick "ceases to be the US Secretary of Commerce for any period of time between market creation and December 31, 2026, 11:59 PM ET" [2]. It also states that an announcement of resignation or removal before the end date resolves the market to Yes, "regardless of when the announced resignation/removal goes into effect" [2]. Because the Polymarket wording turns on announcements and the Kalshi wording turns on actual departure dates, the two are not interchangeable.
Reading the snapshot
The observation time was Nov 19, 2026, 3:00 AM UTC, and the sources were retrieved at 04:07:29Z the same day [1][2]. These are prices from that earlier snapshot, not live quotes.
Kalshi's twelve included markets each ask about a different deadline. Yes prices rise with later deadlines: 0.005 for before November 20, 2026; 0.205 for before January 1, 2027; 0.520 for before April 1, 2027; 0.725 for before January 1, 2028; and 0.885 for before January 1, 2029 [1]. Polymarket lists two markets: 0.055 for a November 30 deadline and 0.175 for December 31 [2]. Their listed end times differ, and the Polymarket Yes prices should not be combined with Kalshi prices. The provider's sampling rule also limits the reading: each event is ranked and capped separately, so the two providers' rankings are not one ordered list.
Reported volume is Kalshi 371,501 contracts and Polymarket $515,759 [1][2]. These totals are in different units, cannot be compared, and do not indicate liquidity or the number of traders.
What remains uncertain
Both samples include all saved markets for these events (partialSample is false), but the providers do not establish that every possible outcome is listed. Quoted prices are snapshots, not executable quotes or verified probabilities. The evidence does not explain why any price moved, and it contains no news about Lutnick's position. Differences in price between a Kalshi and a Polymarket contract reflect different wording and close times, so they should not be treated as an arbitrage opportunity.
References
- Kalshi: Howard Lutnick out as Commerce Secretary?. Provider data observed Nov 19, 2026, 3:00 AM UTC.
- Polymarket: Howard Lutnick out as Secretary of Commerce by...?. Provider data observed Nov 19, 2026, 3:00 AM UTC.
AI-generated analysis based on market data. Not financial advice.
Saved Nov 19, 2026 UTCOverview
This market asks whether Howard Lutnick will leave the office of Commerce Secretary before a specified date. Kalshi and Polymarket each list contracts on the question, but their rules differ in important ways. The Kalshi contracts resolve to Yes if Lutnick leaves the role before the stated cutoff. The rules say he must have an actual departure date and vacate the role within the period. Temporary leaves of absence, suspensions, and recusals do not count unless the person formally and permanently ceases to hold the position [1]. The rules count resignation, retirement, removal, expulsion, recall, and expiration of a term without renewal, whether the departure is voluntary or involuntary [1]. If he leaves and later returns to the role, the contract settles on the initial departure [1]. The Polymarket contracts use a different test. A market resolves to Yes if Lutnick ceases to be Secretary of Commerce for any period of time between market creation and the stated end date, which is December 31, 2026 at 11:59 PM ET for the year-end contract [2]. An announcement of a resignation or removal before the end date resolves the market to Yes immediately, regardless of when the change takes effect [2]. The stated resolution source is official information from the Trump administration, although a consensus of credible reporting may also be used [2]. Because the two platforms use different definitions, a departure announcement, a temporary absence, and a departure that takes effect later could each lead to different outcomes depending on the contract. The Kalshi rule text in the saved excerpt includes an unfilled date placeholder in its opening sentence, so the exact cutoff for any Kalshi contract should be read from the provider's current listing rather than inferred from the excerpt.
Historical Context
Wikipedia's background entry describes Lutnick as having served as the 41st United States secretary of commerce since 2025 [3]. That description is historical background from a retrieved page. It does not establish whether he holds the office on the date of this article, and the current status of the role is reported separately in the application's dated status field.
Why It Matters
The contracts measure whether a specific official stops holding a specific government post within a set period. The Kalshi rules focus on a formal, permanent change in office and exclude temporary leaves [1]. The Polymarket rules focus on whether he ceases to hold the post at any point before the end date, and they treat an announced resignation or removal as sufficient even if it takes effect later [2]. Traders therefore need to read each contract's resolution language, since the same real-world event could be handled differently by the two platforms [1][2]. Contracts with different deadlines on the same platform also measure different windows, so their prices answer different questions.
Snapshot context
The latest published provider snapshot for this topic was observed on 2026-11-17 at 03:00 UTC. It contains listings from Kalshi and Polymarket. Market descriptions and listed closing times define the contracts; they do not establish that the real-world outcome has occurred. This article does not include a separately verified news update. [1]
Frequently Asked Questions
Does a temporary leave of absence count as leaving the role on Kalshi?
No. The Kalshi rules state that temporary leaves of absence, suspensions, or recusals do not constitute leaving the role unless the individual formally and permanently ceases to hold the position [1].
Would an announced resignation resolve a Polymarket contract?
The Polymarket rules say an announcement of a resignation or removal before the market's end date resolves the market to Yes, regardless of when the announced change goes into effect [2].
What happens if Lutnick leaves and then returns to the role on Kalshi?
The Kalshi rules say that if a person vacates the role and then re-occupies it, the contract settles on the initial vacation of the role [1].
What source is used to resolve the Polymarket contract?
The stated resolution source is official information from the Trump administration, and a consensus of credible reporting may also be used [2].
Does a Wikipedia entry confirm whether Lutnick currently holds the office?
No. The Wikipedia entry describes his service since 2025 as background [3], and a retrieved encyclopedia page does not by itself verify a current event or the status of an office on a given day.
AI-written background. References identify the evidence used; Wikipedia links under Learn More are additional reading. Prices and provider rules are dated snapshots. This is not financial advice.
Related prediction markets
Prices are catalog snapshots and may have changed. Check each market's rules and observation time.

Who will leave their role in the Trump administration in 2026?
PM $2.75M · K 7.85M contractsWill Pete Hegseth leave the Trump administration before 2027?
Kalshi: Will Pete Hegseth leave the Trump administration before Jul 1, 2027?
Related contracts
Will Kash Patel leave the Trump administration before 2027?
Kalshi: Will Kash Patel leave the Trump administration before Jul 1, 2027?
Related contracts
Will Howard Lutnick leave the Trump administration before 2027?
Kalshi: Will Howard Lutnick leave the Trump administration before Jul 1, 2027?
Related contracts
Related or unreviewed contracts may settle differently. Their gap is not an equivalent-contract comparison.
Saved prices; check contract rules.

Will the House impeach Trump?
PM $7.26M · K 13.22M contractsPete Hegseth impeached by June 30, 2027?
Kalshi: Will any member of the Cabinet (defined as: the Vice President, Secretary of State, Secretary of the Treasury, Secretary of Defense, Attorney General, Secretary of the Interior, Secretary of Agriculture, Secretary of Commerce, Secretary of Labor, Secretary of Health and Human Services, Secretary of Housing and Urban Development, Secretary of Transportation, Secretary of Energy, Secretary of Education, Secretary of Veterans Affairs, Secretary of Homeland Security, Administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency, Director of the Office of Management and Budget, Director of National Intelligence, Trade Representative, Administrator of the Small Business Administration, White House Chief of Staff) be impeached before Jul 1, 2027?
Related contracts
Trump impeached and removed before 2028?
Kalshi: Will the President be impeached before Jan 20, 2029?
Related contracts
Will Trump be impeached before his term ends?
Kalshi: Will Trump be impeached and removed from office? (Before his term ends)
Related contracts
Related or unreviewed contracts may settle differently. Their gap is not an equivalent-contract comparison.
Saved prices; check contract rules.

Who will leave their role in Sheinbaum’s cabinet?
K 0 contracts
Sean Duffy out as Secretary of Transportation?
K 10.1K contracts
Who will be Trump's next Secretary of Commerce?
K 565.39 contracts
RFK Jr. out as HHS Secretary?
K 10.2K contractsMarket Insights
Price gaps of 2 pp+
0
Same-question pairs
2
Largest saved gap: 1.0 percentage points.
Price differences do not establish arbitrage. Check each pair's review, current order prices, fees and settlement rules.

